Trouble above
Ricardo Costa and Northwest Pasadena residents push to ground noisy and invasive police helicopters
By Justin Chapman 12/17/2009
DIGG | del.icio.us | REDDIT
Other Stories by Justin Chapman
Related Articles
Comments
Oh stop your whining! Northwest Pasadena and Altadena is a hotbed of criminal activity. Law enforcement needs to patrol and respond to calls. Would you rather they not respond? I guess not since you are probably growing marijuana in your backyard! LOL
I'm never certain if responding to trolls is proper netiquette or not, but I suppose I'm willing to take you at your word that you actually care about this issue. To your credit, you did actually comment on this article, thereby helping us to attract the attention of others to this problem, so thank you.
There are adult literacy courses available at PCC and elsewhere, and after you have completed one of them, please re-read the article, taking care to notice that one of the alternatives offered up is the hiring of more police officers. How that would jibe with my desire to conceal my sprawling criminal empire is uncertain, but I have faith that you will both help this discussion by elaborating further.
If I'm correct, you both imagined that your comments would earn you some bizarre form of lickspittle points with the police. I would like to suggest that you'll win them over with greater ease by supporting the idea of putting the Air Operations funds to better use: on personnel. That, and the occasional contribution to the F.O.P. wouldn't hurt.
What, another Pasadena Weekly article based on opinion and speculation only? Let’s get down to the real issues here; Roli and Kevin have a problem with authority. Now the two want to ban the same services that protect them from the real issues that they fear, their neighbors. This is a classic example of someone who bought a run down Craftsman home in the northwest area of Pasadena in a rapidly inflating real estate market. Now, after a few trips to Restoration Hardware and Home Depot, they can’t understand why the rest of their neighborhood have failed to catch up to their over financed properties. Unable to sell or rent, and after being shunned by their latte drinking friends, they need someone to blame. These two can’t cope with the fact that there are people in front of their homes selling corn on the cob out of a Target shopping cart, they fear their “questionable” neighbors, and the cars that go thump-thump are a nuisance. Maybe they should move to Inglewood and start a ban against planes landing at LAX. What is also sad is the lack of factual and truthful reporting done by Justin Chapman. It is obvious that Mr. Chapman did little or no research while writing this piece. “Respond to low priority crime?” What about the high priority crimes? I’m sure there are quite a few in the Northwest. Do the police respond to those? Armor plating and gun turrets? Not to mention the poor Photoshop job of the low flying helicopters. The Pasadena Weekly needs to stick to what they do best, provide a bogus list of top places to eat and drink, (as long as they advertise in the Weekly) and a place for massage parlors and escort services to list their respective ads.
(Part 1 of 2)
I have lived in Pasadena for over 40 years and yes, I also find the nightly noise from the Police helicopters annoying. (My son calls them Ghetto Birds)
I remember many years ago when the Pasadena PD flew Enstroms (many old timers will remember they were bright red – I think the city still has one or two.).
While those were also loud, they didn’t fly nearly the number of hours that the current OH-58 ships do.
The above article mentions that PPD will be purchasing an MD-500E in the near future. It also mentions that it will be quieter due to it’s 4 blade tail rotor design (this is called the “Quiet Knight” option in aviation circles). It will still be comparitively loud.
How do I know ? Well, if you live in the northwest Pasadena area, you’ve already heard something even quieter. Let me explain some things the article fails to mention:
Pasadena PD, Glendale PD, and Burbank PD have been sharing air support duties for at least the last year now. Glendale and Burbank combined their air operations a couple of years ago. To save costs, Pasadena PD’s main ship has been down for a couple of evenings a week while Glendale/Burbank provides our air support. Pasadena PD provides air support to those cities a few nights a week in return.
More info in this article:
http://www.burbankleader.com/articles/20...
The Glendale/Burbank ships are the MD-520N with NO TAIL ROTOR. Yup, it’s a NOTAR design and that particular model is considered the quietest certified helicopter in the world. The military version is the OH-06A.
More info on the MD-520N here:
http://www.airliners.net/aircraft-data/s...
So airships that are even QUIETER than the one Pasadena PD will be purchasing have already been flying over the city a few nights a week. Keep an ear out for them – they do have a different sound.
One of the more annoying things the Pasadena airship will do is if they are at point A and leave for another call several miles away at point B, they will fly with the Night Sun light turned on and pointed down for the entire time, basically “sweeping” the neighborhood with light.
It reminds of the “in the future” scenes in the Terminator movies where the airships are sweeping the landscape with light looking for the rebellion. Why does this light need to be left on when traveling ? If it can’t be switched off, what about tilting it up so it doesn’t shine through hundreds of residential windows when travelling ?
(Part 2 of )
What’s the solution to all of this ? I honestly don’t know. Admittedly, it’s easy to complain here on the forum, but more difficult to come up with solutions.
I think a good start would be develop a policy where the airship isn’t over the Northwest between certain hours unless it RESPONDING to an urgent call for service. (ie. Not proactive patrolling)
The air support units DO provide a valuable service, but reducing the number of flight hours would go along way to abating the noise (and closing the city's budget gap).
Do the math: Above article states the Air Operations budget is 3.3 Million per year. That's over $9,000 PER DAY is costs the city. If you cut that in half and save $4,500 per day, that's 1.6 million a year saved. How many officers could be put on the street (a majority of them deployed to the NW) with that money ?
Probably about 20-25. Better yet, divert the money into long term solutions that creates jobs and educates youth.
Does this affect property values in the Northwest ? That’s hard to quantify, but I can tell you that there was a house for sale 2 doors south of me (Yes, I live in the NW). A couple that were looking to purchase the home did a couple of things I found surprising.
They knocked on several doors in the neighborhood to introduce themselves and meet their potential new neighbors. I only spoke with them for 5 minutes or so, but they explained that they wanted to know a little more about the people they would be living next to for the next 20 years.
We talked about the area and how this particular “pocket” of the NW was not a bad area at all. In the end, they decided not to move here. I ran into the realtor a couple of weeks later and he remembered the couple. He explained that they requested to spend one night (on sleeping bags!) in the home before purchase. The current owner agreed to their request. The couple said it “sounded like a war zone” overnight and that’s why they didn’t purchase the house. It’s been 3 months, and that home is still for sale.
Thoughts ?
-XiliX
I guess if you are a marjijuana farmer you wouldn't like the ghetto birds.
Growing Marijuana outdoors, in this area, during the winter wouldn't provide a very good yield. The nightime temps drop too low and will get colder over the next few weeks.
You're better off setting up a grow room in a closet
using the LED grow lights that draw very little power.
The above in compliance with Assembly Bill 420/Prop 215 of course.
- Xilix
Which actually brings up another good point though...
Let's say it's summer and someone really is growing marijuana outdoors (limited number of plants and
in compliance with Prop 215 for medical reasons).
That LEGAL grow is spotted by the airship. What do you think happens next ? Well, it comes down to one of two things actually:
1. Pasadena PD's SES (Spec Enforcement Section) knocks on the door and requests to see the person's doctor's note for the grow.
2. Pasadena PD's SES (Spec Enforcement Section) knocks on the door, waits the required 10 seconds, then busts the door down, tearing up the homeowner's property, causing several hundreds of dollars in damage, and then later asks the homeowner if they have a doctor's recommendation.
I know what's happened here in the past....
- XiliX
We can further suppose that the helicopters will be circling overhead for a half-hour before the knock on the door, and another 45 minutes afterwards. What we are talking about in the article is only a small part of the problem, admittedly, but what it comes down to is that the helicopters are not a precision instrument; they target entire neighborhoods for the misdeeds (or in the above case, legal deeds) of one individual. That is, simply put, unacceptable.
There is indeed a "paranoid" explanation for all of this, and it's probably right on the money: Making law enforcement as loud as possible increases the fear of and stress about crime, and so boosts support for those same law enforcement procedures and officials. We would be astounded if this equation has not already been noticed and reported elsewhere.
P.S. - So now we have marijuana "farmers" in Pasadena? You would think one would need to grow a full acre of something before earning the title of "farmer"... and you don't need a helicopter to spot an acre.
I think we all want our community to be effectively served by our police force. And it is worth recognizing our Pasadena Police Department brings considerable expertise to the law enforcement issues in our community. Nevertheless, I think the concerns discussed in this article by Mr. Costa and others underscore the point that citizens should have a voice in the way our community is policed. To my knowledge, our community lacks a formal way to express valid concerns and engage in this dialogue. Our police force gains allies when it listens to the genuine concerns of our community members.
I did not realize there were so many people growing marijuana in their yards. Why is this guy Ricardo Costa complaining? Instead, he should be doing something to help clean up his neighborhood!
Attempting to clean up our neighborhood is precisely what we are doing. Please do join us.
I'm sure Mr. Ricardo and his bud DMZ must be tokin' because they sure sound paranoid.
I live in Hollywood, and I agree with the Pasadena residents that it would be nice if the police departments used the funds on more officers or patrolling neighborhoods with cars.
Every time there is a show at a local theater (especially if it's a hip hop show), the LAPD sends out helicopters to circle over our apartments. Most of the time there's no crime reported (i've called to ask why the hell there is a helicopter shining lights into my bedroom at 3am) . Wouldn't it be more cost effective to get a few cars out and just escort the drunk ***holes to jail instead of flying like they're afraid of their own neighborhood?
To "Insider" and "Robert Hurley": Where do you get your statistics? Fay Place is a cozy cul-de-sac and everybody is really quite cordial and neighborly. You think you can surreptitiously insert "high crime rate" and "gang activity" and hope readers subconsciously associate Fay place with crime and marijuana. The issue is unfair policing activity, and not consumption of controlled substances as anybody with but a cursory inspection of the article will find. Drive down Fay Place and see for yourself. It's really quite cute.
Oh "Stew", the name is Keith, not Kevin. So apparently you didn't read the article carefully. Now how was buying a house in a "rapidly inflating real estate market" germane to the issue of oppressive police helicopter presence?
You said: "Respond to low priority crime?” What about the high priority crimes?" -What about them? You miss the point that helicopters are used for low priority crimes instead of just for high priority crimes. That doesn't strike you as unnecessary and excessive?! You must like living in a police state. To adopt your tone, why don't you go live in China? You like police so much. You like not having privacy. You like incessant military and police presence.
You also seem to insinuate that Roli and Keith belong to some lower social strata. Do you really want to test that hypothesis? I don't think you'd win in a contest of education or intelligence. You'd lose!
Furthermore, do you believe poor people are worthless Stew? Should people from low-income neighborhoods suffer from discriminatory policing tactics that would never be tolerated in wealthier neighborhoods like San Marino, or the Arroyo area? I get it- you think they should just put up with it, right? You probably live in an insulated gated community yourself and have gone deaf from blasting your ipod.
To Betty Harris:
I think you've been led astray by wild conjectures of marijuana-growing made by hostile commentators. The issues the article stresses are the excessively loud noisees police helicopters generate till 2am and their oppressive and willfully intimidating presence on the whole of the community to ostensibly deter crime. I say ostensibly because the police have not, and are not able to, justify their "need" for police helicopters other than for mere convenience. They quote things like "surveying traffic"- hardly critical for fighting crime. They have balked at a Public Records Act request for all data pertaining to the effectiveness of the Air Operations program and have failed to produce evidence for its necessity for several months!
This is the issue. Not marijuana.
Citizen San Marino and South Pas don't have ghetto birds because there is no ghetto full of gang bangers there! Duh!
What a bunch of cry babies. These spoiled brats live in a neighborhood riddled with crime yet they have the nerve to complain about law enforcement.
He cant be that smart "citizen," look at that dumb smile on his face. Since when does a "news orginization" if thats what you want to call the Weekly need to photoshop a helicopter to get a point across?
I have been trying to get something done about the rediculous amount of helicopter surveilance and noise pollution for at least the last 2 years. I've written the mayor, spoken to the heliport captain and spoke in front of the safety committee at the heliport when the "investigated" the situation. The Pasadena Police Department apparently believes it is above the law and have no problem annoying the citizens of the city. As a real estate broker, I KNOW the noise problem and invasion of privacy are affecting real estate values. Try relaxing in your hot tub with the war of the worlds buzzing over your back yard. It's pathetic!
This quote from Capt.Mulhall is total crap. “If a helicopter is circling a neighborhood, something bad is going on there,”. HA! WRONG. They employ these noisy helicopters for such mundane chores as searching for standing water for mosquito abatement!! Helicopters are the city's first response whenever they are in the air no matter how routine the call, so their statistics about calls responded to and arrests made are total crap too!! Don't believe it!!! There is no citizen oversight of the Pasadena Police Department, and they like it that way. Don't kid yourself, the cops use these choppers for force protection.... that is, to make themselves feel safe whan they go on a call or make a traffic stop. Its nice when a noisy chopper with a big light is there when your feeling afraid.
I am a homeowner in a very respectable neighborhood in $600k-$1,000,000 price range and yes, live above the 210.
Police helicopter traffic begins around 4pm and ends around 11pm EVERY NIGHT.
The threshold of noise is low, at night you can hear someone talking across the street from inside the house, thus helicopter traffic is very annoying and does get on your nerves night after night. We pay for a reasonably decent place to live and feel compromised. I do have to say, though, my neighbor is very trigger happy and will call police at any suspicion, mostly after midnight. No helicopter response but a quick reply from a squad car. Made me feel quite safe, congrats, fellas.
But poses a question, why 4pm-11pm when most people are trying to enjoy family life at home? Can't the police fly operations during the daytime or very late at night?
Does crime really begin at 4pm and cease at 11pm?
Say what ever you want in a derogatory way, but Mr. Chapman is intelligent and not reactionary or shall I say buzzed off of 'legal' vices when he types like perhaps some of these replyees.
I'm not concerned with the 'invasion of privacy'. I have nothing to hide. But this noise has GOT TO stop. The vibration and noise from the helicopters are not only affecting my sleep, it literally has caused a worsening of my migraines. It's a health hazard. I'm sure some people will say 'if you don't like it, then move.'. There has to be a better solution to this. Having to chose between my health and my home just doesn't seem right to me.
http://www.pasadenastarnews.com/news/ci_...
These helicopter crybabies are marijuana farmers - Look here--busted by the ghetto birds! HaHa
You live on Fay Place which is in an area known for it's high crime rate and gang activity. Is that your concern Mr. Costa? No. You are consumed in a blanket of paranoia and truly believe that the police are actually spying on you and others when not actually on their way to, or working an active call. What is it that you have base this on Costa? Have photos of your house, it's interior, your marijuana gardern in the backyard suddenly surfaced?
Tell ya what! Why doesn't the City designate you home and yard as a free zone for criminals. Yeah, they will be told that under no circumstance can a police helicopter search for them on your property and therefore, no police officer can legally enter you abode or front or back yards due to lack of probable cause. They are home free and happy and you are noise free and happy. Understand though, that should these individuals take advantage of you or your family while hiding on you property, you cannot summon police. They can't come on to your property, even if they got your permission, because it would be a violation of a City Ordinance. How about that you whining, little, simp?